Business Analyst or Subject Matter Expert: Which Does Your Project Need?
Business Analysts (BAs) and Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) carry different responsibilities and expertise into a project, yet employers often confuse the two roles. Some job adverts call for such deep domain knowledge that it is hard to tell whether they want a BA or an SME with BA experience. A BA's skillset is transferable and designed to be applied across different projects; building up too much SME knowledge can weaken that skillset and make it harder for a BA to move into other areas and domains of the business. Domain knowledge does matter for a BA, along with the curiosity to expand it as needed, so drawing a clear line between the two roles is important.
Who Are Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)?
SMEs provide deep knowledge and expertise in a specific subject area or industry domain. An SME might, for instance, represent the finance, procurement or operations area of a particular business entity. Knowledge in any area is never static, and never less so than today, so keeping up with developments and best practices matters for the SME. This allows them to offer the most current insights, guidance and validation, ensuring project solutions meet both their area's requirements and industry standards. SMEs not only contribute invaluable input to the project but also review documentation relating to their expertise and make decisions.
What Do Business Analysts (BAs) Do?
BAs focus on analysing business processes, gathering requirements and facilitating communication among stakeholders so that technology solutions meet business needs. They bring strong analytical, communication and problem-solving skills and are proficient in techniques such as requirement elicitation, process modelling and data analysis. BAs hold a broad understanding of business domains, project management methodologies and technology solutions, though they may lack deep expertise in a specific industry or subject area. Acting as intermediaries between business stakeholders and technical teams, they translate business requirements into technical specifications, manage project scope and ensure solutions deliver value to the organisation.
How Business Analysts and Subject Matter Experts Work Together
While the BA usually joins the project team for the duration of the project, the SME comes in on a need-to basis to provide input within their domain. Once the project ends, the SME typically returns fully to their day-to-day role, having been a borrowed resource for a designated period and purpose. The BA, by contrast, is then either deployed on a different project or the whole project team is dismantled and their presence is no longer required after handover to the business. In the latter case, the BA can be deployed to a completely different business domain, industry and environment, because BA techniques and tools can be flexed and adapted to suit any domain or industry. The BA needs to be curious and willing and able to develop the required knowledge to build credibility with stakeholders and facilitate project success.
In summary, both BA and SME roles are critical to project success, bringing different perspectives and skills to ensure project solutions meet business objectives and industry requirements. For more details, view our Business Analyst site.


Browse Categories
Connect With Etomix
Follow us and stay in touch:
Drag A: Newcastle, NSW 2300, Australia
T: +61 423 218010 E: [email protected] T: +61 429 842 077
Search Back to TopSubscribe to Our Newsletter
Sign up to stay updated on the latest industry trends, new services and expert tips to optimise your business. Your email address is used only to send our newsletter and information about Etomix activities, and you can always unsubscribe via the link included in the newsletter.
Email Address* Name
SubscribeData-Driven Excellence
Etomix offers a new way to optimise your business through IT Business Analysis, Master Data Management, Procurement Spend Analytics and a Procurement Savings Tracker, all custom-tailored solutions.
Etomix Pty Ltd · Privacy Policy
